Tuesday, March 22, 2005

Pakistani Identity Crisis?

Hey everyone,

Two days ago, I was at a conference and there I met with an Indian. We were talking about stuff and suddenly he asked me: where are you from? I told him to take a guess. He said he was not sure and I encouraged him to take a guess! He started ranting off; American, British, European and I was like NO, NO and NO. He finally settled on: Canadian. He was so sure I was a Canadian, and he even picked out Toronto as my hometown. I told him: Sorry to burst your bubble, but I am from Pakistan and before you go on about anything else, I am 100% Pakistani. His jaws dropped.

I know there are lots of generalizations and stereotypes floating out there. Everyone's perception of what a Pakistani is basically someone who is short, dark, not so good looking and in the labor class. I wouldn't blame for thinking that way since majority of the Pakistanis in the Middle East are like that.

Which brings me to the point: what defines a Pakistani? Does it make less of a Pakistani if I listen to English songs, wear American branded clothes, watch Hollywood Movies and read Western novels? I dont watch cricket and I dont eat spicy foods nor drink tea, all of which is typical Pakistani. Does that make me less of a Pakistani? Does it make me less Pakistani if I dont wear my national dress? Or if I dont know the national anthem? I have lived abroad my whole life, and only two years in Pakistan when I went to the high school.

So sometimes it is very confusing for people like me who have lived abroad out whole lives to understand what it is to be a Pakistani. However, in my opinion, I think one is a Pakistani when one is a proud patriot of the country he/ she is from. I dont think one needs to wear the national dress, listen to Pakistani music, watch cricket and eat spicy foods to be a Pakistani. I identify with my country of Pakistan, and even though the political/ economic situation in the country is not worth mentioning, I still have a love for my country. Sure there are some things in the nation that I dont agree with, namely corruption, but that does not change the fact that I am a Pakistani. In fact, it only strenghthens my desire to do something for the betterment of Pakistan.

I think one is a Pakistani when one learns to love oneself and understands where one is coming from. In my case, I dont do all that what Pakistanis do, but in my heart I know I will always be a Pakistani. I will never in my lifetime say that I am half Pakistani half Saudi, or anything like that. I can fool a lot of people and say, I am half American half Pakistani and talk in an American accent, but I dont do that. In any case, I have a lot of fun telling people I am from Pakistan because it immediately breaks the stereotypical image, and people think: hmm, so not all Pakistanis are like what we thought they would be!

So, one is not a Pakistani when one listens to Pakistani music, wear the national dress, watch cricket, know the national anthem or speak Urdu. One is a Pakistani when one can identify with the nation of Pakistan and learns to be a patriot and proud of the country he/she is from.

Proud Pakistani,
Mansur

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

mansur--- my heart melts to read about someone who is obviously so proud of his birth nation. i am equally sad to see so many pakistanis who are ashamed to tell other people they are pakistanis, and instead tell them they are americans, british or europeans. you display a strong sense of patriotism and i agree with you. in the same way, i dont have to vote for bush, eat hot dogs, listen to michael jackson to be an american!

Sam

Anonymous said...

mansur: I m sooooo proud of you ..you dont have to feel ashamed becouse you are from Pakistan ..there are many ppl who respect and love your country more than any europeans or american countries(like me) .. at least you dont harm others or attack other countries for no suitable reason .. be always proud ..i wish u all the best ..(by the way i think its ok if u said im half pakistani half saudi ..let ppl from KSA as me feel proud for having such a good and educated man like YOU) ...

Mansour said...

Hi Sahar,

thanks for your comments. I appreciate it. I dont think I will be able to say I am 1/2 saudi 1/2 Pakistani because there is no saudi-ness in me. I dont know the arabic language! :) But I have lived in Jeddah, and I always consider that my second home! I love it better than Dubai!

Mansur

Anonymous said...

i can totally understand what u had to go thru...i interact with a lot of indians here...and they all have this image....its really not their fault...its cause of all the pakistanis that do live here....and what they show themselves as....way to go by the way...im very proud to be pakistani too...may Allah help us in fixing our country...

patriotically happy :)

H.A

Powered By Blogger